| | 1683–1693 | Kristofer Heidemann (um 1623–1703)  |
| | 1693–1695 | Andrés Iversen Rafn (d. 1695) |
| | 1695–1702 | Jens Jörgensen (f. um 1653) |
| | 1702–1717 | Páll Pétursson Beyer (d. 1717) |
| | 1717–1727 | Kornelíus Wulf (d. 1734) |
| | 1727–1739 | Kristján Luxdorf (d. 1751) |
| | 1739–1749 | Kristján Drese |
| | 1749 | Guðni Sigurðsson (1714–6.01.1780) Íæ II. 196 |
| | 1749–1793 | Skúli fógeti Magnússon (12.12.1711–9.11.1794) Íæ IV. 291–292, V. 560, JÁ I. 413,570–71, III. 434, 600, IV. 156, V. 425 |
| | 1763–1786 | Jón Skúlason (11.11.1736–10.03.1789) Íæ III. 273 |
| | 1786–1787 | Hans Jakob Líndal |
| | 1793–1794 | Magnús Ólafsson Stephensen (27.12.1762–17.03.1833) Íæ III. 457–458 |
| | 1794–1804 | Paul M. Finne |
| | 1804–1813 | Rasmus Frydensberg |
| | 1813–1828 | Sigurður Björnsson Thorgrímsen (9.10.1782–21.02.1831) Íæ IV. 271–272, JÁ I. 404 |
| | 1828–1836 | Christian Ulstrup |
| | 1831–1832 | Ólafur Hannesson Finsen (22.05.1793–24.02.1836) Íæ IV. 42–43 |
 | 1835–1836 | Þórður Sveinbjarnarson (4.09.1786–20.02.1856) Íæ V. 113–114 |
| | 1836–1838 | Morten Hansen Tvede (4.12.1791–1.03.1840) Íæ III. 482 |
| | 1838–1849 | Stefán Gunnlaugsson (9.10.1802–13.04.1883) Íæ IV. 320–321 |
 | 1849–1851 | Kristján Kristjánsson (21.09.1806–13.05.1882) Íæ III. 378, JÁ II. 166 |
 | 1851–1852 | Jón Pétursson (16.01.1812–16.01.1896) Íæ III. 248–249, V. 551 |
 | 1852–1860 | Vilhjálmur Lúðvík Finsen (1.04.1823–23.06.1892) Íæ V. 65–66 |
| | 1859–1861 | Hermann Johnson (17.12.1825–2.04.1894) Íæ II. 351 |
 | 1861–1904 | Árni Thorsteinson (5.04.1828–29.11.1907) Íæ I. 71–72 |